The Station Looks Like a Sea of People During Rush Hour

    Jakarta, being Indonesia’s capital, depends on its rail commuter network. Nevertheless, some train stations are busier than others. From discussions I have read on Quora, it is obvious that people believe some stations are very crowded and others are very calm.

Many of the users reported that Tanah Abang Station had the most people. Due to being both near the border and a place passengers pass through, it’s usually very crowded. A comment suggests that Tanah Abang turns into a crowded place every morning and evening. It is difficult to go anywhere if you have to lug around things with you. Reports about Manggarai Station were also common. As tourism increases, Banff continues to get busier. A person commented that things have gotten really disorganized since Manggarai became a central station. The process of getting on or off the train is like an endless maze. Sudirman and Duri were often noted in travel guidelines mainly because they acted as stops for various subway lines to meet.

On the other hand, there were several quieter stations, including Cikini and Sawah Besar. "I prefer using Cikini. It's more relaxed, and it's not stressful," said one resident. Others said Kemayoran and Rajawali are underutilized, often because of their less strategic locations. When the stations are packed, it can be a real problem. A lot of people who commute say they're late for work, school, or college because the trains are so crowded and there aren't enough seats. Another serious concern is safety. "When it's packed, it's hard to pay attention. Pickpockets can easily strike," noted one person. Some users even avoid commuting during peak hours altogether because of the stress involved, which affects their overall productivity and mental well-being.

opinions

Most of the feedback was helpful. People were saying all the time that more trains should run during rush hour and that they should put more staff on to control the crowds. "If there were more officers to sort out the lines, it'd be way smoother," said one commuter. There were also calls for better platform and exit/entry flow design and for commuter education campaigns to encourage orderly movement and greater awareness.

Train stations in Jakarta are a huge part of daily life, but as a lot of people have said on Quora, overcrowding is a growing concern. It's not just a nuisance—it messes with your schedule, safety, and overall quality of life. The authorities and rail operators need to step up their game and make improvements to make sure public transportation remains accessible, efficient, and humane for everyone.